?

Log in

No account? Create an account
The Titfield Thunderbolt Hue and Cry Whisky Galore The Man in The White Suit Previous Previous Next Next
Little Grey Cells - The Titfield Thunderbolt
Heisenberg might have stayed here
qatsi
qatsi
Little Grey Cells
Book Review: Hercule Poirot - The Complete Short Stories, by Agatha Christie
This volume collects the short stories into chronological order, from 1923 to 1941. There is quite a variety, though inevitably a few repeated themes emerge. What strikes me in particular is that the first four or five do seem very weak indeed - extremely lightweight and not well put together. The Disappearance of Mr Davenheim in particular seems to borrow ideas rather heavily from Conan Doyle.

But as she gets into her stride, the stories do seem generally more well thought out. In this edition, some of the longer stories are described as "extended versions" of the originals, and these work very well; one can readily transpose them in principle to the superb David Suchet ITV series. For the shorter stories, one imagines that the script writers must have had to dream up padding material to fill the one-hour slots. (The two-hour episodes are generally from full-length novels).

For me, Poirot is most successful when in England: be it in the metropolis, the shires or the seaside. Some of the short stories are set abroad, typically around the Mediterranean and Egypt, and these don't work so well. I suspect that to some extent it is a matter of changing times: whilst the whole world has obviously changed since the 1920s, Poirot's European travels are simply not exotic and the preserve of the upper classes the way they were eighty years ago.

Another thing that strikes me is just how much Christie relies on supposition and confession. Many of Poirot's cases would never stand up in a court of law. But it's a fun parallel universe to visit.


In other news, my copy of Verdigris Deep arrived today. I know what I must do next.

Tags:
Current Music: Shostakovich - Jazz Suite No 1

3 comments or Leave a comment
Comments
uitlander From: uitlander Date: May 9th, 2007 08:31 pm (UTC) (Link)
Well I've just had a response to my complaint to Amazon about my copy not being dispatched yet. Apparently they are now sending it, although they haven't explained the delay. They don't seem to be able to write in English either, so I think THOs job is safe for a while.
uitlander From: uitlander Date: May 9th, 2007 08:39 pm (UTC) (Link)
And apparently after my complaint, the book is now showing a dispatch date as 23rd June. WTF?
thegreenman From: thegreenman Date: May 10th, 2007 08:00 am (UTC) (Link)
"first four or five do seem very weak indeed"

Mmmm... a complaint that can also be aimed at Conan Doyle. The Sherlock Holmes stories vary considerably in quality. Possibly reflecting Doyle's changing level of interest and financial state.

3 comments or Leave a comment