?

Log in

No account? Create an account
The Titfield Thunderbolt Hue and Cry Whisky Galore The Man in The White Suit Previous Previous Next Next
Top Ten New Who - The Titfield Thunderbolt
Heisenberg might have stayed here
qatsi
qatsi
Top Ten New Who
I was intrigued by green_maia's top-ten episode list a week ago - probably because of her positive comments about RTD, whereas my thoughts about him are mostly negative - and decided I should compile my own.

So, in chronological order (and with season number and writer):
The Doctor Dances (1, Moffat)
Bad Wolf (1, RTD)
School Reunion (2, Toby Whithouse)
The Girl in the Fireplace (2, Moffat)
The Impossible Planet (2, Matt Jones)
Blink (3, Moffat)
The Fires of Pompeii (4, James Moran)
The Unicorn and the Wasp (4, Gareth Roberts)
Vincent and the Doctor (5, Richard Curtis)
The Pandorica Opens (5, Moffat)

I notice that her list is composed entirely of single-episode stories, whereas mine has a few two-parters (there were even more of those in my short-list, and it appears that I do generally prefer the set-up of the story over its resolution in those cases), though it's probably an accidental distinction, and a reasonable inference that my list would remain the same if it was stories rather than episodes. Interestingly, Moffat is the only writer with more than one credit in my list; the only RTD episode that got dropped from my initial list was Rose, which leaves Bad Wolf (and implies The Parting of the Ways) as his only contribution in the list. Season 3 now looks particularly weak, which isn't quite how I wrote about it at the time. I don't have any specials in my list; some of them were fun, but none was outstanding.

(Episodes which were removed from my initial shortlist to bring the number down to 10 were: Rose, The Empty Child, The Parting of the Ways, The Satan Pit, Daleks in Manhattan, Evolution of the Daleks, Human Nature, The Family of Blood, Utopia [on its own], The Sontaran Stratagem, The Poison Sky, Silence in the Library, Forest of the Dead, The Hungry Earth, Cold Blood, and The Big Bang.)

Compiling a top ten that combines Classic and New Who will also be an interesting task, but it will take a bit more thought.

Tags:

2 comments or Leave a comment
Comments
From: rosaguestlist Date: June 28th, 2010 06:30 pm (UTC) (Link)
Top ten for the new series:

1. The Girl in the Fireplace
2. Silence in the Library / Forest of the Dead
3. Blink
4. The Empty Child / The Doctor Dances
5. The Waters of Mars
6. The Time of Angels / Flesh and Stone
7. Amy's Choice
8. The Eleventh Hour
9. The Fires of Pompeii
10. Planet of the Dead

Top 20 overall:

1. The Girl in the Fireplace
2. The Chimes of Midnight
3. Logopolis
4. Silence in the Library / Forest of the Dead
5. Colditz
6. Castrovalva
7. The Curse of Fenric
8. Loups Garoux
9. Warrior's Gate
10. The Aztecs
11. City of Death
12. The Natural History of Fear
13. Mawdryn Undead
14. A Thousand Tiny Wings
15. The Mind Robber
16. The Abominable Snowmen
17. Arrangements for War
18. The Keeper of Traken
19. The Robots of Death
20. The Magic Mousetrap

- K
(Deleted comment)
2 comments or Leave a comment