Log in

No account? Create an account
The Titfield Thunderbolt Hue and Cry Whisky Galore The Man in The White Suit Previous Previous Next Next
Carry On Up Mumbai Business District - The Titfield Thunderbolt
Heisenberg might have stayed here
Carry On Up Mumbai Business District
I went to Reading Film Theatre last night to see The Lunchbox. Once I'd got over the inflation (now £7.50, up from £5.50 the last time I went) I enjoyed the film. From the opening credits it's not entirely clear to what extent it's an Indian film; the funding seemed to come mostly from France and Germany. It was bizarre, but seemed quite plausible, that the dialog would randomly switch between Hindi and English. Some of the characters were quite stereotypical - such as the old woman known only as "Auntie" who lives in the flat above Ila. Like Mrs Mainwaring, she is never seen, although she certainly has plenty of "wisdom" (and chillies) to impart. The plot centres around Saajan Fernandes, a widower nearing retirement working in a large Mumbai insurance office, and Ila, a housewife in a stale marriage. Somehow (there is no unambiguous explanation, although the opening scenes with the dabbawalas make it all too clear the number of opportunities for error), Ila's lunch box is exchanged with one from the shop with which Fernandes has a regular order. He notices the difference in the food quality (and Ila notices on the boxes' return that the meal has been polished off and the boxes "look as though they have been licked clean"); conversely, the event passes Ila's husband by without observation. Ila places a note in the box the following day, and as the error is repeated a correspondence begins. Meanwhile Fernandes is disinterested in his replacement who has started in the office and appears enthusiastic though neither entirely competent nor entirely honest. Really this is quite a sad tale on many counts, but it's portrayed with a lightness of touch and nostalgia that means a smile is never too far away, and there is also some quite dry humour (one particular example would be the dialogue in the scene late in the film where Ila challenges the dabbawala about the error). The story doesn't really resolve itself - though any "resolution" would inevitably be contrived so perhaps it is best up to the viewer to imagine.


2 comments or Leave a comment
lamentables From: lamentables Date: May 29th, 2014 11:00 am (UTC) (Link)
Switching between Hindi and English like that seems pretty standard in middle class India.

'Auntie' is how you address/refer to any older woman (uncle for older men). I used to be addressed as 'didi' or sister when strangers wanted to photograph me or be photographed with me, but since I've stopped dyeing my white hair I've become 'auntie'.
qatsi From: qatsi Date: May 29th, 2014 08:50 pm (UTC) (Link)
That makes sense, thanks for the explanation.
2 comments or Leave a comment