qatsi (qatsi) wrote,
qatsi
qatsi

Brigade Leader Mickey

It seems with the new Who, I either like them, or I have mixed feelings about them, which may be my way of saying I don't like them without actually saying so. And I had mixed feelings about this one.

To be fair, there were quite a few good things in this episode. Jake grew on me and I liked "Mrs Moore" from the start - I wondered whether the name "Angela Price" was supposed to be significant? kharin commented that it would be interesting to re-introduce the character in our universe; it was certainly disappointing that she didn't survive the episode. I wonder whether she might appear again later in the season, or maybe even in Torchwood. I liked the way neither of Rose's "parents" cared for her in the parallel universe. The Mickey/Ricky thing was clever and resolved itself superficially, though on nwhyte's journal, various people have observed that the fate of Ricky's grandmother remains uncertain.

But on the negative side, magic_wanderer is quite correct that it was a collection of set-pieces. The storyline doesn't really hold up to any deeper inspection. The resolution of the cliff-hanger was clunky, to say the least; Lumic was a rather wooden villain - in fact quite a bit of the acting and dialogue was wooden - and why did Lumic, as the post-upgrade Cyber Leader, need that Jim'll Fix It Cyber Sofa?

In Confidential David Tennant marvelled at the Mickey "story arc", which beggars belief. I've never been a great fan of the Tyler-family-RTD-soap style, but it just doesn't work for me that Mickey finally joins the TARDIS crew, only to leave a couple of stories later - and in a place where they will never see him, and he will never see them, again. The reasons for Mickey leaving seem fair enough, perhaps it's a question of timing. I'm tiring of Rose quite quickly now; as a character her development seems to be mostly negative, whilst Tennant is getting quite a lot more to do than Eccleston had.

And it's another return to Earth next week. We were promised "alien worlds" in this season, but I don't think that has been properly realised yet.
Tags: who
Subscribe
  • Post a new comment

    Error

    default userpic

    Your reply will be screened

    When you submit the form an invisible reCAPTCHA check will be performed.
    You must follow the Privacy Policy and Google Terms of use.
  • 1 comment